| Platinum | Frankie's Italian Kitchen & Bar |
| Gold | Red Swan Pizza |
| Gold | The Greek Islands Restaurant |
| Silver | Bozzini's Restaurant |
| Bronze | The Old Spaghetti Factory |
| Top Pick | Boston Pizza |
| Top Pick | Delagios Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Jim's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Jo's Italian Deli |
| Top Pick | Paliotti's Italian Restaurant & Bar |